Riding the Business Cycle

The Permanent Portfolio needs no forecast. That is not the same as ignoring the weather. In Business Cycle Investing we met the four seasons of the economy. In The Permanent Portfolio we met Harry Browne’s answer: own one asset for each. This piece puts the two together.

This article is adapted from Lesson 4 of The Macro Butler Financial Academy, Riding the Business Cycle with the Permanent Portfolio.

Reading the season with two questions

Economists describe the cycle in four phases: expansion, peak, contraction and trough. Useful, but you only know where the peak was once it has passed. Markets offer a faster read, using two questions:

  • Boom or bust? Compare stocks with oil. When stocks lead, the economy is booming. When oil leads, it is under strain.
  • Inflation or deflation? Compare gold with government bonds. When gold leads, inflation is in charge. When bonds lead, deflation is.

Two answers give four seasons, and each season has its asset:

  • Inflationary boom: stocks.
  • Inflationary bust: gold.
  • Deflationary bust: cash.
  • Deflationary boom: long-term government bonds.

That is the whole Permanent Portfolio, mapped onto the calendar of the economy. Browne did not need to know which season was coming. He simply made sure he owned the right coat for each.

Why the season still matters

If the portfolio is balanced, why bother reading the cycle at all? Because it tells you which part of the portfolio is doing the work, and why. It explains the drift that triggers rebalancing. And it stops you from abandoning the asset that is out of season just before its turn comes round. Knowing the season is not for trading. It is for staying calm.

Two sources of value

Lesson 4 goes one level deeper, into what value actually is. There are two kinds:

  • Scarcity value, the oldest and most certain: a Picasso, an ancient statue and, above all, gold. It is anchored in the past, permanent and immutable.
  • Efficiency value: the tools, machines and capital that produce tomorrow’s goods and services, measured today by the stock market. It is anchored in the future, and therefore uncertain.

Bond markets price the value of time. Equity markets price the expected output of productive capital. Between them, markets constantly arbitrate between the permanence of gold and the promise of stocks.

The ratio that removes the currency

Prices are quoted in currencies, and currencies can be debased. When the unit of account wobbles, the link between price and value breaks. One way round it: divide a US equity index by the price of gold. The dollar cancels out, and what is left is efficiency measured against scarcity.

Over time, efficiency should win and the ratio should rise. When it instead stays below its long-term average for years on end (seven, in the lesson’s rule of thumb), that is a signal of structural weakness, not a passing storm. It is one of the clearest windows into which season we are really in.

Learn the full lesson

Lesson 4 of The Macro Butler Financial Academy covers it in full, with the slides and video: the four seasons, the asset for each, the two sources of value and the stocks-to-gold ratio. US$50 a month or US$500 a year.

You cannot choose the season. You can choose to be dressed for all four.

This article is general information and education, not personal investment advice.

Share Post

Latest on Substack

Passive AggressivePassive AggressiveRead on Substack