Most investors treat the economy like the weather: something to complain about, never something to plan for. Yet the economy has seasons, and they arrive in the same order every time. Spring, summer, autumn, winter. Each one rewards different assets and punishes others. Business cycle investing is simply the habit of knowing which season you are in before choosing what to wear.
This article is adapted from Lesson 2 of The Macro Butler Financial Academy, The Business Cycle.
What the business cycle is
The business cycle is the recurring pattern of expansion and contraction in economic activity. It has four phases, and none of them lasts forever:
- Expansion. Businesses produce more, jobs are added, incomes and spending rise. Growth feeds growth. Think of a plant reaching for the sun.
- Peak. The economy runs at full capacity. Unemployment is low, spending is strong and inflation starts to stir as resources stretch. The top of the roller coaster: maximum prosperity, and a hint that the ride is about to dip.
- Contraction. Growth slows, hiring stops, confidence fades. A hot-air balloon on its way down. If it lasts, it becomes a recession.
- Trough. Activity hits bottom and pessimism peaks. A swing at its farthest point back, pausing before it moves forward again.
The irony is that each phase plants the seed of the next. Prosperity breeds excess; excess breeds the correction; the correction clears the ground for the next expansion.
The engine underneath: four costs
Why does the cycle turn? Follow the costs. Growth depends on four of them: the cost of energy (economic activity is energy transformed), the cost of labour, the cost of capital (interest rates and access to credit) and the cost of government (taxes, regulation and red tape). When those costs fall, the economy accelerates. When they rise, it chokes. Every boom and every bust can be traced back to at least one of them.
The credit cycle: the amplifier
Running alongside the business cycle is the credit cycle: easy money, a borrowing peak, tightening, then a credit drought. Easy credit turns a healthy expansion into a bubble. Tight credit turns a slowdown into a rout. Watch only the economy and you will be early; watch only credit and you will be late. Watch both.
The four seasons, and what wins in each
- Spring: the deflationary boom. After a bust, rate cuts and fiscal support revive growth before inflation returns. Financial markets thrive: stocks and bonds rally together, growth stocks most of all.
- Summer: the inflationary boom. The economy heats up and inflation rises. Cyclicals, emerging markets and commodities lead. Cash starts losing its value as a store of wealth; stocks and gold preserve purchasing power.
- Autumn: stagflation. Inflation forces rate hikes, which hit growth first. The worst season for most assets, with two exceptions: gold and US dollar cash.
- Winter: the deflationary bust. Inflation finally breaks as the economy falls into recession. Long-term Treasuries outperform everything, and cash, kept scarce by tight policy, quietly regains its value.
No asset wins every season. The one that wins this season is usually the one everyone wishes they had sold last season.
How to tell which season you are in
Official statistics are a rear-view mirror: published late and revised later. Markets look ahead. The lesson shows two market ratios that do the job without waiting for the government:
- Stocks against oil. When equities outrun energy over the long run, companies are producing efficiently: a boom. When energy outruns equities, the real economy is under stress: a bust.
- Gold against bonds. When gold beats bonds, the currency is losing its grip as a store of value: an inflationary phase. When bonds beat gold, money is holding its value: a deflationary phase.
Put the two together and you get a map with four quadrants, one for each season, read from prices rather than press releases.
Learn the full lesson
Lesson 2 of The Macro Butler Financial Academy covers the business cycle in full, with the slides and video: the four phases, the credit cycle, the four seasons and how to build and read the two market ratios. It is the foundation for what follows, including Riding the Business Cycle with the Permanent Portfolio and four lessons on the costs of energy, labour, capital and government. US$50 a month or US$500 a year.
Seasons do not ask permission. Neither does the cycle. Dress accordingly.
This article is general information and education, not personal investment advice.
